These jeans turned out exactly as I had hoped! Sturdy denim, took a few days to break in, and now fit like a glove. I definitely need to get them shortened, but for now I'm just cuffing them. I am 5'5", weigh around 110 lbs, generally take either a 24 or 25 in jeans (usually 25), or a 00 in Everlane pants. I originally ordered the 25, but they were too big, so I exchanged for a 24 which fit perfectly (meaning, they were pretty tight when I first put them on, but I knew they would stretch out a little, and after about a week they are great). By comparison, I bought a 25 in the Haywood black, and while they are a teeny tiny bit on the loose side, I would definitely not side down to a 24 in those. Be aware that the ink can rub off a little (not much), so be a little careful to not sit on something bright white until you break these in.
These jeans fit great and feel great wearing all day! Shipping was fast and service is very good!
Buying it on the website required me to enter my order three times. Not a great experience. However, the item once ordered was delivered correctly the first time.